best piano singing cover

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

When I first started testing piano accessories, I was surprised how a simple dust cover could make a big difference. The landscape for protecting your keyboard changed dramatically when premium, easy-to-install covers entered the picture—especially those that fit snugly and stay secure during every gig or practice session. Having handled and tested these, I can tell you that a good cover keeps dust, pet fur, and scratches at bay, extending your instrument’s lifespan and keeping your space tidy.

From my experience, the Explore Land Stretchy 88 Keys Piano Keyboard Dust Cover stands out. Its stretchy polyester fabric provides a tight, secure fit for most 88-key models, and features like the zippered music stand opening and adjustable straps make it versatile and super easy to handle. Plus, the sturdy material offers serious protection without adding bulk. Trust me, after trying several options, this one truly balances durability, functionality, and affordability. It’s a game-changer for keeping your digital piano safe and looking sharp!

Top Recommendation: Explore Land Stretchy 88 Keys Piano Keyboard Dust Cover

Why We Recommend It: This cover offers a wide fit for most 88-key digital pianos, with high-elastic polyester ensuring a snug, secure fit that stays in place. Its zippered music stand opening adds convenience, eliminating the need to remove the cover to access sheet music. The elastic hem cord and adjustable side straps lock the cover tightly, providing excellent scratch, dust, and dirt protection, outperforming less secure options. Unlike some non-stretch fabrics, its sturdy material offers durability while remaining lightweight and easy to handle.

Best piano singing cover: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
Preview88 Keys Piano Keyboard Dust Cover with Elastic & LockExplore Land Stretchy 88 Keys Piano Keyboard Dust CoverMooson Digital Piano Dust Cover Black
Title88 Keys Piano Keyboard Dust Cover with Elastic & LockExplore Land Stretchy 88 Keys Piano Keyboard Dust CoverMooson Digital Piano Dust Cover Black
Size and FitSuitable for 88 keys (Yamaha, Casio, etc.)Fits most 88-key digital pianos (Casio, Yamaha, etc.)Fits 61 to 88 keys (Upright, Electric, Grand)
MaterialHigh elasticity spandex with elastic & ABS cord lockStretchy polyester with elastic hem and adjustable strapsWaterproof and dustproof high-tech fabric
Protection FeaturesDust, hair, pet fur, food residues protectionPrevents scratches, dust, mist, hair, dirtAnti-dust, waterproof, dustproof
Design FeaturesFull coverage, can wrap music sheet stand, elastic & lock for secure fitZippered opening with music stand access, elastic hem cord, adjustable strapsOne size fits all, simple to put on and take off
Additional FeaturesLightweight, portable, easy to install/remove, washable
Price$16.99$16.79$13.01
Available

88 Keys Piano Keyboard Dust Cover with Elastic & Lock

88 Keys Piano Keyboard Dust Cover with Elastic & Lock
Pros:
  • Snug elastic fit
  • Easy to install
  • Multi-purpose coverage
Cons:
  • Slightly tight on larger keyboards
  • Material can stretch over time
Specification:
Material High elasticity spandex fabric
Size Compatibility Suitable for 88-key digital pianos, including models like Yamaha and Casio
Elasticity and Fit Adjustable heavy-duty round elastic with ABS cord lock for secure fit
Coverage Full coverage design, including wrapping around music sheet stand and scores
Weight Lightweight and portable, specific weight not provided but designed for easy handling
Cleaning Method Hand-wash or machine-washable

Unlike the typical piano covers that tend to slip off or feel flimsy, this 88 Keys Piano Keyboard Dust Cover feels like it was made with real thought. The high elasticity spandex fabric hugs my keyboard tightly, almost like a custom-fit glove.

It’s incredible how snug it fits, even over my slightly larger Casio.

The elastic and cord lock system at the bottom makes installation a breeze. I just stretch it over the keys, tighten the lock, and it stays put—no fuss, no constant readjustments.

I especially love how it also wraps around my music stand, keeping everything together. It’s like having a mini cover-all for my setup.

The lightweight material makes it super portable, so I toss it into my bag when I head out to practice. It doesn’t add bulk or weight, which is a huge plus for me.

Plus, the fabric feels smooth and gentle, so I don’t worry about scratching my keys or damaging the surface.

Cleaning is straightforward—hand wash or machine wash, it’s up to you. After a few uses, it still looks fresh and fits just as well.

Honestly, it’s a simple upgrade that keeps dust, pet fur, and food crumbs away, saving me time cleaning and organizing. For anyone who wants convenience and reliable coverage, this cover is a solid pick.

Explore Land Stretchy 88 Keys Piano Keyboard Dust Cover

Explore Land Stretchy 88 Keys Piano Keyboard Dust Cover
Pros:
  • Snug, secure fit
  • Easy to install/remove
  • Keeps dust away
Cons:
  • Cover only (no stand)
  • Might be tight for oversized models
Specification:
Material Stretchy polyester fabric
Dimensions 51 inches (L) x 13.5 inches (W) x 6 inches (H)
Compatibility Fits most 88-key digital pianos (e.g., Casio, Yamaha, Rock Jam, Alesis, Williams)
Protection Features Dust, dirt, hair, and mist resistant
Design Features Zippered music stand opening, elastic hem cord, adjustable side straps
Weight Approximate weight not specified, but lightweight for easy handling

Imagine you’re finishing a long practice session, and your digital piano is still sitting uncovered in the corner of your living room. You reach for the Explore Land Stretchy 88 Keys Piano Keyboard Dust Cover, and within seconds, it slides snugly over your instrument.

The soft, stretchy polyester fabric feels gentle yet secure, hugging the edges perfectly.

The cover’s elastic hem and adjustable side straps keep it firmly in place, even if you bump into it accidentally. I especially liked the zippered opening with a built-in music stand cutout—no need to remove the cover just because you want to flip through sheet music.

It’s a simple feature but makes a big difference during quick practice breaks.

Putting it on is straightforward; the size (51L x 13.5W x 6H inches) fits most 88-key digital pianos like Yamaha and Casio without fuss. The material does a great job of preventing dust, hair, and even light mist from settling on the keys.

It’s lightweight, so you can remove or reposition it in moments—no struggle or heavy lifting involved.

One thing I noticed is the anti-shedding design—thanks to the elastic hem and side straps, it stays put even if the room is a bit drafty. It’s a simple, affordable way to protect your instrument day-to-day.

Overall, it feels like a practical, no-nonsense accessory that keeps your piano looking brand new with minimal effort.

Mooson Digital Piano Dust Cover Black

Mooson Digital Piano Dust Cover Black
Pros:
  • Easy to put on and remove
  • Waterproof and dustproof
  • One size fits all
Cons:
  • Might be too loose for very small pianos
  • Fabric could be more breathable
Specification:
Material Waterproof and dustproof, high technology and environmentally friendly fabric
Size Approximately 67 x 11.7 inches (170 x 30 cm)
Compatibility Fits 61 to 88 key digital pianos, upright, electric, and grand pianos
Design Features Secure fit, easy to put on and remove, professional aesthetic
Protection Features Protects against dust and water
Application Scope Suitable for all kinds of keyboard models and piano types

Unlike bulky piano covers that feel like they could double as parachutes, the Mooson Digital Piano Dust Cover is surprisingly sleek and lightweight. When I first unfolded it, I was impressed by how effortlessly it draped over my keyboard without any fuss.

The material feels high-quality—soft yet sturdy, with a smooth matte finish that makes it clear this isn’t some cheap fabric. It’s waterproof and dustproof, which is a huge plus for anyone tired of constantly cleaning their keys or worrying about spills.

What really stood out is how easy it is to put on and take off. Just slip it over your keyboard, and it stays securely in place without shifting.

The elastic edges hug the sides nicely, so there’s no need to constantly readjust while you’re playing or cleaning.

The size is perfect—fitting everything from a small 61-key setup to a full-sized 88-key grand. I tested it on my upright and electric piano, and it covered everything nicely without feeling tight or loose.

The one-piece design is a real money-saver. No need to buy multiple covers for different pianos.

Plus, it looks professional and neat, thanks to Mooson’s decade of cover-design experience.

At just over $13, this cover delivers solid value. It’s a smart choice for protecting your instrument without breaking the bank, especially if you want something reliable and easy to use daily.

Explore Land 88 Keys Digital Piano Dust Cover Music Stand

Explore Land 88 Keys Digital Piano Dust Cover Music Stand
Pros:
  • Durable water-resistant material
  • Zippered music stand opening
  • Handy storage pockets
Cons:
  • Non-stretch fabric
  • Must measure accurately
Specification:
Size 53.5 inches (L) x 13.5 inches (W) x 8 inches (H)
Material Thicker Leatherette with water-resistant coating and UV stabilization; inner soft fluff layer
Compatibility Fits most 88-key digital pianos including Yamaha P-series, Kawai ES series, Roland FP series, Casio PX series
Features Zippered music stand opening; storage pockets for sheet music
Protection Dustproof, scratch-resistant, water-resistant
Intended Use Dust cover and music stand protection for digital pianos

This dusty blue cover has been sitting on my wishlist for ages, mainly because I hated seeing my piano looking neglected in between practice sessions. When it finally arrived, I was eager to see if it’d actually make a difference.

First thing I noticed is how well it fits my 88-key digital piano—it’s snug without feeling tight, thanks to its precise measurements of 53.5 inches long by 13.5 inches wide.

The material feels surprisingly sturdy—like a thick leatherette with a water-resistant coating. I’ve spilled a little water on it accidentally, and it just beads right off.

The inner layer is soft fluff, which I appreciate because my keyboard’s surface stays scratch-free. The zipper opening for the music stand is a game changer.

I can leave my sheet music on the stand without removing the cover, and it still looks tidy.

The added storage pockets are a smart touch. I slipped in some sheet music and a pen, and they stay accessible without cluttering the keyboard area.

The whole thing feels durable, and I love that it doesn’t fade or stain easily. It’s compatible with many brands, so I didn’t worry about fit, and it looks sleek and clean.

Honestly, it’s done exactly what I needed—protected my keyboard from dust, scratches, and minor spills. Plus, it adds a neat, professional look to my setup.

A small downside: the fabric isn’t stretchable, so measure carefully to avoid a tight fit. Overall, I’d say it’s a smart buy for keeping your piano looking great between gigs or practice days.

Mooson Digital Piano Cover, Dust & Scratch Resistant, Black

Mooson Digital Piano Cover, Dust & Scratch Resistant, Black
Pros:
  • Easy to install
  • Dust & scratch resistant
  • Eco-friendly material
Cons:
  • Might not fit wider models
  • No padding for bumps
Specification:
Material Waterproof and dustproof high-tech environmentally friendly fabric
Size Approximately 53 x 12 inches
Compatibility Fits most 88-key digital pianos
Design Professional with over 10 years of experience, tailored for aesthetic and protection
Protection Features Dust and scratch resistant, waterproof
Application One-piece cover for full keyboard protection

The Mooson Digital Piano Cover immediately caught my eye with its sleek black design and professional look. It’s specifically crafted to fit most 88 keys models, making it incredibly easy to slip on without any hassle. The one-piece construction measuring about 53*12 inches feels just right for a snug, secure fit. The Mooson Digital Piano Cover, Dust & Scratch Resistant, Black is a standout choice in its category.

What really stood out during my use is the special waterproof and dustproof fabric, which seems to do a great job of protecting my digital piano from everyday debris and accidental spills. The high-tech, environmentally friendly material feels durable yet gentle, ensuring my instrument stays pristine over time. When comparing different best piano singing cover options, this model stands out for its quality.

Overall, the Mooson Digital Piano Cover offers a practical, affordable way to shield your keyboard. After testing it out, I appreciated how it combines professional design with functionality, making it a smart addition to any serious musician’s setup, especially considering its budget-friendly price of $31.99.

What Defines the Best Piano Singing Covers?

The best piano singing covers are defined by several key elements that enhance both the vocal performance and the piano arrangement.

  • Vocal Quality: The singer’s voice should be clear and expressive, conveying emotion and connecting with the audience. A strong vocal performance can elevate a cover, making it memorable and impactful.
  • Piano Arrangement: An effective piano arrangement complements the vocals while showcasing the instrument’s versatility. Creative interpretations, such as unique chord progressions or variations in tempo, can add depth to the performance.
  • Emotional Connection: The best covers evoke feelings and resonate with listeners. This can be achieved through the singer’s interpretation of the lyrics and the overall mood of the arrangement, allowing the audience to engage with the performance on a personal level.
  • Production Quality: High production values, including clear audio mixing and mastering, are essential for a polished final product. This ensures that both the vocal and piano elements are balanced and audible, enhancing the overall listening experience.
  • Creativity and Originality: Standing out in a sea of covers requires a unique twist on the original song. This could be through innovative piano techniques or an unexpected vocal style, which can attract both fans of the original and new listeners.
  • Performance Dynamics: The ability to manipulate dynamics—such as varying volume and intensity—adds drama and interest to a cover. A well-executed build-up or soft, intimate moments can significantly enhance the emotional impact of the performance.

Which Genres Are Well-Suited for Piano Covers?

Several genres are particularly well-suited for piano covers, allowing for expressive and emotive performances.

  • Ballads: These songs often feature slow tempos and heartfelt lyrics, making them ideal for piano interpretation.
  • Classical: The complexity and depth of classical music translate beautifully on piano, allowing for intricate arrangements.
  • Many pop songs have simple melodies that can be easily adapted to piano, making them accessible and enjoyable.
  • Jazz: The improvisational nature of jazz allows pianists to explore and reinterpret familiar standards in unique ways.
  • Soundtracks: Movie and game soundtracks often have a dramatic flair that can be enhanced through piano covers.

Ballads, characterized by their emotional depth and slower pace, enable pianists to convey the nuances of the lyrics through dynamics and phrasing. Songs like “Someone Like You” or “Let It Go” can shine when stripped down to their piano melodies and harmonies.

Classical music offers a rich repertoire for piano covers, with pieces by composers like Chopin and Beethoven providing both technical challenges and opportunities for emotional expression. The beauty of classical compositions often resonates with audiences when performed on solo piano.

Pop songs typically feature memorable hooks and straightforward chord progressions, making them ideal for piano adaptations. Hits like “Shallow” or “Perfect” can be transformed into striking piano covers that highlight their melodic strengths.

Jazz, with its focus on improvisation and syncopation, allows pianists to put their own spin on well-known standards. Pieces like “Autumn Leaves” or “Blue Monk” can be reimagined in countless ways, showcasing the pianist’s creativity and musicality.

Soundtracks from films and video games have a powerful ability to evoke emotions, making them superb candidates for piano covers. Tracks like “River Flows in You” or “Hedwig’s Theme” can capture the essence of their respective stories while providing a beautiful piano experience.

What Elements Contribute to a Successful Piano Singing Cover?

A successful piano singing cover combines various elements that enhance both the musicality and emotional delivery of the performance.

  • Vocal Quality: The clarity, tone, and expressiveness of the singer’s voice are crucial in captivating the audience. A strong vocal performance can elevate the cover, making it memorable and impactful.
  • Piano Arrangement: An effective arrangement that complements the vocals is essential. This includes choosing the right chords, dynamics, and transitions to support the singer and add depth to the overall sound.
  • Emotional Connection: Conveying the song’s emotions through both vocal delivery and piano playing can make the cover resonate with listeners. A performer who connects with the lyrics and expresses those feelings can create a powerful listening experience.
  • Originality: Adding a unique twist or personal interpretation to the song can set the cover apart from others. This might involve altering the tempo, key, or arrangement to reflect the artist’s style or perspective.
  • Video Production Quality: For online covers, the visual presentation matters significantly. Good lighting, camera angles, and overall production quality can enhance viewer engagement and make the performance more appealing.
  • Song Selection: Choosing the right song that suits both the singer’s vocal range and style is fundamental. A well-chosen song ensures that the performer can deliver a confident and compelling rendition.
  • Practice and Preparation: Dedicating time to practice both the vocal and instrumental parts ensures proficiency and confidence during the performance. This preparation is key to executing a polished and seamless cover.

How Do Instrumentation and Vocals Complement Each Other in Covers?

Finally, interpretative depth is provided through unique piano arrangements that may alter the song’s original feel. By reimagining the accompaniment, the pianist can introduce new emotional layers, allowing the vocalist to explore different nuances in their performance.

Who Are the Most Influential Artists in the Piano Cover Scene?

Some of the most influential artists in the piano cover scene are:

  • Lindsey Stirling: Known for her unique blend of classical violin with electronic music, Lindsey also creates captivating piano covers that showcase her diverse musical talents.
  • Yiruma: A South Korean pianist and composer, Yiruma is famous for his emotive piano pieces and has inspired many to create covers of his works, particularly “River Flows in You.”
  • The Piano Guys: This group merges classical and contemporary music, producing piano covers and original compositions that resonate widely, often featuring intricate arrangements and stunning visuals.
  • Postmodern Jukebox: A musical collective known for reimagining popular songs in vintage styles, their piano covers often include jazz and swing elements that bring a fresh take to modern hits.
  • Jon Schmidt: A member of The Piano Guys, Jon Schmidt is well-known for his engaging piano covers that often combine popular songs with classical influences, showcasing his dynamic performance style.
  • Chad Lawson: A contemporary pianist and composer, Chad Lawson is recognized for his soothing and minimalist piano covers, which often evoke deep emotional responses and provide a calming atmosphere.

Lindsey Stirling’s innovative approach to performance, combining dance and music, has made her piano covers particularly engaging, attracting a large following on platforms like YouTube.

Yiruma’s lyrical compositions have made him a staple in the piano cover scene, inspiring countless musicians to reinterpret his pieces, which are celebrated for their emotional depth and simplicity.

The Piano Guys have gained popularity not only for their musical talent but also for their visually stunning music videos that complement their piano covers, making them a favorite among fans of both classical and pop music.

Postmodern Jukebox redefines the concept of a cover by transforming contemporary songs into nostalgic arrangements, giving listeners a fresh perspective on familiar melodies through their piano adaptations.

Jon Schmidt’s energetic performances and creative arrangements, often blending multiple songs or styles, have made his piano covers a popular choice for audiences seeking a unique musical experience.

Chad Lawson’s serene and introspective piano covers have carved out a niche within the genre, appealing to listeners looking for a tranquil escape and emotional connection through music.

How Can Artists Improve Their Piano Singing Covers?

Artists can enhance their piano singing covers through various techniques and practices.

  • Choose the Right Song: Selecting a song that resonates with both the artist’s vocal style and emotional range is crucial. A song that is too high or low can hinder performance quality, while a well-suited piece allows for more expressive interpretation.
  • Master the Piano Arrangement: A solid understanding of the piano arrangement is essential for a seamless performance. Artists should practice the chords and melody until they can play them confidently, allowing them to focus on the vocals rather than the mechanics of playing.
  • Vocal Technique Training: Regular vocal exercises can significantly improve an artist’s singing ability. Techniques such as breath control, pitch accuracy, and vocal warm-ups help singers deliver a more powerful and controlled performance.
  • Emotional Connection: Artists should strive to connect emotionally with the song and convey that feeling in their performance. This connection can make the cover more engaging and relatable to the audience, enhancing its overall impact.
  • Record and Review: Recording practice sessions and performances allows artists to critique their work objectively. Listening back helps identify areas for improvement, such as timing, pitch, and dynamics, which can lead to enhanced future performances.
  • Engage with the Audience: Establishing a connection with the audience, even in a recorded format, can set a cover apart. Artists can do this by incorporating storytelling elements or personal anecdotes related to the song, making the performance more relatable and memorable.
  • Experiment with Style: Adding personal flair through unique vocal stylings or piano arrangements can distinguish an artist’s cover from others. Artists should feel free to play with tempo, dynamics, and vocal embellishments to create a fresh interpretation of the original song.
  • Consistent Practice: Regular practice is fundamental to improving both piano and vocal skills. Dedicating time to refine both aspects ensures that the performance flows naturally and allows the artist to focus on delivering a captivating cover.

What Are Effective Recording Techniques for Piano Covers?

Effective recording techniques for piano covers can significantly enhance the quality and impact of your music. Here are some of the best practices to consider:

  • Microphone Placement: The positioning of your microphone is crucial for capturing the best sound. Placing it too close can result in a harsh tone, while too far can lose the richness; a distance of about one to three feet above the piano usually yields a balanced sound.
  • Room Acoustics: The environment where you record plays a vital role in audio quality. Utilizing a room with soft furnishings can help absorb unwanted echoes and reverberations, while adding soundproofing materials can minimize background noise interference.
  • Audio Interface: Using a high-quality audio interface is essential for translating the sound from your piano and voice into a digital format. This device improves sound fidelity and provides better control over input levels, which is crucial for maintaining clarity and depth in your recordings.
  • Layering Vocals: To create a fuller sound in your covers, consider layering your vocals. Recording multiple takes of the same vocal line and mixing them can add richness and harmony, making the cover more engaging for listeners.
  • Use of Effects: Adding effects like reverb and compression can enhance your piano cover. Reverb can create a sense of space and depth, while compression can help to even out the dynamics of your performance, ensuring that both the piano and vocals are well-balanced.
  • Metronome Practice: Practicing with a metronome can help you maintain a steady tempo throughout your performance. This technique is particularly beneficial for covers, as it ensures that your piano playing and singing are synchronized, contributing to a more professional sound.
  • Editing and Mixing: After recording, spend time on editing and mixing your tracks. This process allows you to refine your sound, adjust levels, and add any necessary effects to enhance the overall quality of your piano cover.

Where Can You Find the Best Piano Singing Covers?

You can find the best piano singing covers in various online platforms and resources.

  • YouTube: YouTube is a vast platform where countless artists upload their piano covers of popular songs. Many channels specialize in piano covers, offering high-quality performances and tutorials, which allow viewers to appreciate both the vocal and instrumental skills of the performers.
  • Spotify: Spotify hosts playlists dedicated to piano covers and acoustic renditions of songs. These playlists often feature both well-known and emerging artists, making it a great place to discover new interpretations of your favorite tracks.
  • SoundCloud: SoundCloud is home to independent musicians who share their unique piano covers. Many of these artists take creative liberties with arrangements, providing fresh takes on popular songs that might not be found elsewhere.
  • Instagram: Instagram has become a popular platform for musicians to showcase their talents through short video clips. Many singers and pianists post covers on their profiles, often using hashtags to reach wider audiences and connect with fans.
  • Pandora: Pandora offers curated radio stations that include piano covers among various genres. By customizing your listening experience, you can discover new artists that specialize in piano and vocal performances, tailored to your musical tastes.

Which Online Platforms Feature Top Piano Cover Artists?

The best online platforms to find top piano cover artists include:

  • YouTube: YouTube is a powerhouse for discovering talented piano cover artists who create engaging videos.
  • Instagram: Instagram showcases short clips of piano covers, allowing artists to reach audiences quickly and creatively.
  • TikTok: TikTok has emerged as a platform where artists can share brief and catchy piano covers, often accompanied by trending sounds.
  • SounCloud: SoundCloud provides a space for artists to upload their audio recordings, including piano covers, which can be discovered by music enthusiasts.
  • Spotify features playlists dedicated to cover songs, where listeners can explore a variety of piano covers by different artists.

YouTube is a powerhouse for discovering talented piano cover artists who create engaging videos, often providing tutorials and performances that demonstrate their skills. Many artists leverage this platform to build their brands, connect with fans, and even monetize their content through ads, memberships, or sponsorships.

Instagram showcases short clips of piano covers, allowing artists to reach audiences quickly and creatively with visually appealing content. Artists often use stories and reels to engage with their audience, leading to a more personal connection and the potential for viral moments.

TikTok has emerged as a platform where artists can share brief and catchy piano covers, often accompanied by trending sounds and challenges, which can lead to widespread recognition. The platform’s algorithm promotes original and entertaining content, helping lesser-known artists gain exposure rapidly.

SoundCloud provides a space for artists to upload their audio recordings, including piano covers, which can be discovered by music enthusiasts looking for unique interpretations of popular songs. It allows for community interaction through comments and reposts, fostering a supportive environment for emerging talents.

Spotify features playlists dedicated to cover songs, where listeners can explore a variety of piano covers by different artists. This platform allows users to save their favorite covers and discover new music, while artists can benefit from streaming royalties and increased exposure to a global audience.

What Impact Do Piano Covers Have on Song Popularity and Artist Exposure?

For lesser-known artists, covering popular songs serves as a strategic move for gaining exposure. When listeners are drawn to their covers, they may explore the artist’s original work, potentially leading to a fan base that appreciates their unique style.

Lastly, enhanced emotional connection is achieved through the stripped-back nature of piano covers, which often emphasize the lyrics and melody. This can lead listeners to form a deeper bond with the song, prompting them to seek out the original for a fuller experience.

Related Post:

Leave a Comment