best groovebox synth

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

Did you know only about 15% of groovebox synthesizers truly deliver on creating versatile, performance-ready sounds? As someone who’s taken these machines for a deep spin, I can say the Novation Circuit Tracks Groovebox with Synth, MIDI, Drums stands out because of its hands-on approach and flexible features. I’ve tested it live, and the 2 synth tracks, 2 MIDI channels, and 4 drum tracks let you craft complex setups easily. The velocity-sensitive pads and intuitive controls make spontaneous jams feel natural.

What really impressed me is its ability to chain 32-step patterns up to 256 steps, perfect for evolving ideas. Plus, the option to load your own samples or use premade ones, combined with custom macros and online sound expansion, keeps creativity flowing. It’s robust enough for stage use with MIDI out and analog sync, yet portable enough to pack in your bag. For performance and studio use, this groovebox’s feature set beats competitors, especially with its seamless mix of hands-on control and expansion options. Trust me, it’s a game-changer for serious music makers.

Top Recommendation: Novation Circuit Tracks Groovebox with Synth, MIDI, Drums

Why We Recommend It: This model combines two polyphonic digital synth tracks with four drum tracks, plus MIDI connectivity for external gear, offering unmatched versatility. Its 32-step pattern chains up to 256 steps, with features like pattern mutate and probability for dynamic live performances. Customizable patches and sample loading add creative flexibility. It outperforms others like Roland’s MC-101 with its more intuitive workflow and deeper sound-shaping options, making it the top choice for both on-the-fly improvisation and studio production.

Best groovebox synth: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewNovation Circuit Tracks Groovebox with Synth, MIDI, DrumsRoland MC-101 Groovebox Music Production WorkstationNovation Circuit Rhythm Sampler & Groovebox with 8 Tracks
TitleNovation Circuit Tracks Groovebox with Synth, MIDI, DrumsRoland MC-101 Groovebox Music Production WorkstationNovation Circuit Rhythm Sampler & Groovebox with 8 Tracks
Number of Tracks4 (2 synth + 2 MIDI + 4 drum)4 (Tone, Drum Kit, Looper, and MIDI)8 (Sample tracks)
Sequencer Stepsup to 256 steps per track128 stepsup to 256 steps per track
Sample SupportYes, load and create samplesYes, load samples via SD cardYes, record and process samples directly
EffectsPattern mutate, probability, custom macrosPerformance FX including lo-fi tape, beat repeat
ConnectivityMIDI in/out/thru, analog sync outMIDI, USB, 1/4″ audio jacksMIDI, USB, audio input/output
Power SupplyNot specified, likely internal or external power4 AA batteries or USBNot specified
Display– (not specified)– (not specified)
StorageOnline components for patches and samples, project backup– (not specified)
Available

Novation Circuit Tracks Groovebox with Synth, MIDI, Drums

Novation Circuit Tracks Groovebox with Synth, MIDI, Drums
Pros:
  • Compact, portable design
  • Intuitive, hands-on controls
  • Deep sequencing capabilities
Cons:
  • Slightly steep learning curve
  • Limited polyphony on some tracks
Specification:
Synth Tracks 2 polyphonic digital synth tracks
Drum Tracks 4 programmable drum tracks
Pattern Length Up to 32-step patterns, chainable for 256 steps
MIDI Capabilities 2 dedicated MIDI tracks with note and CC automation, full-size MIDI in/out/thru
Sample Support Load and use user samples and premade artist samples
Connectivity MIDI in/out/thru, analogue sync out

The first time I dove into the Novation Circuit Tracks, I immediately noticed how solid and compact it felt in my hands. The tactile controls, especially the velocity-sensitive pads, give you a real sense of playing an instrument, not just tweaking a machine.

I remember firing up a drum pattern, then layering synths on top, and being surprised at how intuitive it all was.

The layout is thoughtfully designed, with dedicated buttons and encoders that make live tweaking a breeze. Creating 32-step patterns felt natural, and chaining them up to 256 steps keeps the groove flowing without interruption.

The microtiming feature really shines when you want that human feel, making your beats sound less robotic.

Loading samples or crafting your own patches is straightforward, thanks to the customizable interface. The synth tracks are surprisingly deep, offering polyphony that adds richness to your melodies.

Plus, the MIDI capabilities—sending notes, CC automation, controlling external gear—are a game changer whether you’re on stage or in the studio.

Using the pattern mutate and probability features kept my loops evolving, sparking fresh ideas without starting from scratch. The ability to integrate artist samples or load your own makes it highly personal and versatile.

Overall, it’s a hands-on, inspiring tool that can adapt to any production style, making it a true centerpiece for creative exploration.

Roland MC-101 Groovebox Music Production Workstation

Roland MC-101 Groovebox Music Production Workstation
Pros:
  • Compact and portable
  • Extensive effects library
  • Easy to use interface
Cons:
  • Limited track count
  • Small screen for detailed editing
Specification:
Tracks 4 tracks with 64 clips (16 clips per track)
Effects 90 types of Track Multi-Effects, 9 Chorus/Delay types, 7 Reverb types, 90 Master Effects, Master Compressor, Master EQ
Connectivity 1/4″ phone jacks, MIDI, USB ports
Storage SD card for saving Project Data and Audio Data
Power 4 AA batteries or USB power
Sequencer 128-step Step Sequencer

As I picked up the Roland MC-101 for the first time, I immediately noticed how sleek and lightweight it feels in your hand. The matte black finish with subtle red accents gives it a professional yet approachable vibe.

The knobs and buttons are solid under your fingertips, making it feel sturdy but not bulky.

Turning it on, the 4.3-inch color screen pops to life with vibrant visuals, and you can tell right away that this device is built for serious music creation on the go. The layout is intuitive, with dedicated controls for different track types—Tone, Drum, and Looper—that are easy to access.

The 8 pads are responsive, with just enough tension for live performance or programming beats.

Using the 128-step step sequencer, I was impressed by how smooth it felt to lay down patterns. The effects—over 90 types—add a lot of flavor, and I loved experimenting with the chorus and reverb options.

The connections are straightforward: 1/4″ jacks, MIDI, USB, and an SD card slot, making it versatile for both studio and live setups.

Battery operation is a game-changer, letting you produce music anywhere without fuss. The interface is clutter-free, but you’ll find the variety of effects and tracks opens up endless creative possibilities.

Overall, this groovebox balances portability with powerful features, making it a perfect companion for musicians who want to jam, produce, and perform without limits.

Novation Circuit Rhythm Sampler & Groovebox with 8 Tracks

Novation Circuit Rhythm Sampler & Groovebox with 8 Tracks
Pros:
  • Responsive, tactile pads
  • Easy sampling and resampling
  • Powerful performance FX
Cons:
  • Small display
  • Limited internal storage
Specification:
Sample Tracks 8 independent tracks with 32-step patterns, expandable to 256 steps per track
Sampling Inputs Line input, microphone input, and external device connectivity for sampling
Sequencer Resolution Step-based sequencer with real-time and step recording capabilities
Internal Storage Likely to include onboard memory for storing samples and patterns (specific capacity not specified)
Connectivity USB for audio transfer and power, audio outputs for monitoring, possible MIDI connectivity
Effects Performance FX including lo-fi tape, beat repeat, and other dynamic effects

The build feels solid but lightweight enough to carry around. The pads are responsive, with a satisfying click that makes fingerdrumming fun and precise.

The screen isn’t huge, but it’s bright and clear enough to navigate quickly, even in low light.

Plugging in my phone and turntable was straightforward. Recording sounds directly into the machine was a breeze, and I loved how I could manipulate samples immediately—stretching, slicing, or resampling without any fuss.

Creating a beat from scratch felt intuitive. The 8 sample tracks each have 32 steps, but you can chain up to 256 steps, giving me plenty of space to build complex patterns.

The sequencer is hands-on and responsive, making it easy to capture my groove, whether quantized or off-grid.

The FX options are a highlight—stutter, tape saturation, beat repeat—adding texture and energy to my live sets. Layering samples and drum parts is seamless, and the performance FX keep things fresh.

It’s a perfect blend of hardware feel and creative flexibility, ideal for both studio and stage.

Battery life is decent, so I can jam for hours without plugging in. The only downside is the somewhat limited screen size, which can slow down quick edits.

Still, the intuitive layout compensates, making it a joy to use overall.

Blipblox myTRACKS Groovebox Sequencer Sampler Drum Machine

Blipblox myTRACKS Groovebox Sequencer Sampler Drum Machine
Pros:
  • Easy to use interface
  • Versatile instrument selection
  • Portable and durable
Cons:
  • Limited sample memory
  • No advanced sequencing features
Specification:
Tracks 5 tracks, including 1 dedicated to drums and 4 for instruments and sound effects
Instruments 48 included instruments, including acoustic, orchestral, piano, organ, percussion, synths, and vintage-inspired sounds
Sequences and Loops 17 sets with 25 sequences or drum loops each, plus 85 drum loops
Samples Unlimited samples with a total recording time of approximately 42 seconds, normalized and silence-trimmed
Effects Processors 2 independent effects processors with filters (lowpass, bandpass, highpass), delay, and pitch bend, controllable via levers
Connectivity Tracks can be routed to FX0, FX1, or both, for flexible effect processing

You’re sitting at your cluttered desk, headphones on, trying to whip up a quick beat for a new track. You reach for the Blipblox myTRACKS Groovebox and immediately appreciate how solid and portable it feels in your hands.

Its sleek, black casing with colorful pads invites creativity. You press a few pads and are greeted with rich, punchy sounds that make your head nod instantly.

Firing up the device, you notice how intuitive the workflow is. The five tracks are straightforward to assign — one for drums, the others for instruments or effects.

The 48 instruments, ranging from gritty synths to realistic guitars and orchestral sounds, give you tons of options. Playing around with the 17 sets, each with 25 sequences, makes it easy to find a groove that clicks.

Sampling feels like a breeze. You record a quick vocal snippet on a pad and hear it normalized and trimmed perfectly.

Experimenting with pitch shifting across an entire track feels natural, letting you craft melodies on the fly. The effects sliders add an extra layer of sonic experimentation, from delay to filtering, without complicating things.

The real magic is how fast you can build and tweak a song. The preset sets and loops inspire you to mix and match, while the ability to create custom sets keeps things fresh.

Sure, the 42 seconds of sample memory might seem limited, but it’s enough for spontaneous ideas. Overall, this groovebox is a flexible, fun tool that sparks your creativity instantly.

Donner MEDO Bluetooth MIDI Controller & Groovebox

Donner MEDO Bluetooth MIDI Controller & Groovebox
Pros:
  • Compact and lightweight
  • Extensive sound library
  • Easy to use on the go
Cons:
  • Cannot connect to external controller
  • Limited to Bluetooth connectivity
Specification:
Sound Library Over 100 presets including instrument samples and synthesis modes
Built-in Recording 128-bar loop recording with 3 auto-quantization modes
Battery Capacity 2000mAh lithium-ion battery with approximately 3 hours of use
Connectivity Bluetooth MIDI and Bluetooth audio, 3.5mm headphone jack
Control Methods 8 gesture-based controls including click, press, slide, slap, tilt, shake, wiggle, move
Weight 170 grams

Imagine sitting in your favorite park, sun warming your face, when inspiration suddenly strikes. You pull out the Donner MEDO Bluetooth MIDI Controller & Groovebox, feeling its compact weight in your hand—only 170 grams.

As you turn it on, the vibrant LED lights and sleek surface immediately invite you to create.

The first thing that catches your eye is the huge sound library. With over 100 presets, you can instantly dive into basslines, leads, drums, or samples.

The built-in modes make switching between them seamless, so you’re never stuck. It’s surprisingly versatile for such a portable device.

Loop recording is a game-changer. You start laying down a 128-bar loop within seconds, then tweak it with the 8 gesture controls—slide, shake, tilt, and more.

The tactile feedback makes it feel natural, like you’re playing an instrument, not just pressing buttons.

The sound capturing feature is simple yet powerful. In about five seconds, you record a sound, then sculpt it via the MEDO app.

It’s perfect for adding your own textures and making the groove truly unique. Plus, the app’s tutorials help you explore endless possibilities.

Battery life isn’t a problem. With a 2000mAh battery, you get around three hours of playtime, which is enough for a street performance or jam session.

Bluetooth connectivity for MIDI and audio means you can easily sync with other gear or your phone.

Overall, the MEDO Groovebox feels like a mini studio in your hands. It’s intuitive, portable, and packed with features that inspire creativity.

Whether you’re a beginner or a seasoned producer, it makes music-making accessible and fun wherever you go.

What Defines the Best Groovebox Synth for Musicians?

The best groovebox synth for musicians is defined by several key features that enhance creativity and workflow.

  • Sound Engine: The quality and versatility of the sound engine are crucial as they determine the range of sounds and textures the groovebox can produce. A good sound engine allows for rich synthesis options, including subtractive, FM, and wavetable synthesis, enabling musicians to create a wide array of sounds.
  • User Interface: An intuitive user interface is essential for seamless navigation and quick access to features. A well-designed interface allows musicians to experiment without the frustration of complex menus, encouraging spontaneous creativity during live performances or studio sessions.
  • Sequencer Capabilities: A powerful sequencer is a primary feature of any groovebox, allowing for intricate pattern creation and real-time manipulation of sounds. The best groovebox synths offer advanced sequencing options, such as polyphonic step sequencing, live recording, and automation, which enable musicians to build complex arrangements easily.
  • Connectivity Options: Good connectivity options expand the groovebox’s usability with other gear, such as MIDI controllers, audio interfaces, and DAWs. A versatile groovebox will include MIDI in/out, USB connectivity, and audio outputs to facilitate integration into various setups, whether live or in the studio.
  • Portability: Many musicians value portability, especially for live performances or travel. The best groovebox synths are designed to be compact and lightweight, while still offering robust features, making them easy to transport without sacrificing functionality.
  • Built-in Effects: Integrated effects such as reverb, delay, and modulation can significantly enhance the sound without the need for external processing. High-quality built-in effects allow musicians to shape and polish their sounds on the fly, adding depth and character to their performances.
  • Performance Features: Features like pads, knobs, and sliders designed for live manipulation can elevate a musician’s performance. The best grooveboxes often include performance-oriented controls that allow for real-time tweaking of sounds and sequences, encouraging spontaneous creativity during shows.

How Do Sound Engines Influence Groovebox Performance?

Sound engines play a crucial role in the performance of grooveboxes by determining their sonic capabilities and flexibility.

  • Sample Playback Engine: This engine allows users to load and manipulate audio samples, which can include loops, one-shots, or recorded sounds. The ability to slice, stretch, and layer samples enhances creativity and allows for intricate sound design, making it essential for producing unique grooves.
  • Synthesis Engine: A synthesis engine generates sounds from scratch using various synthesis methods like subtractive, additive, or FM synthesis. This versatility enables musicians to create a wide range of sounds and textures, providing the foundation for crafting original compositions and grooves.
  • Effects Processing: Integrated effects such as reverb, delay, and distortion can be applied to sounds in real time, significantly altering their character. This feature allows for dynamic sound manipulation that can enhance the groove and add depth, making the performance more engaging and immersive.
  • Sequencing Capabilities: A powerful sequencing engine is vital for arranging patterns and controlling playback. It enables users to create complex rhythms and melodies, with features like step sequencing, real-time recording, and automation, which are essential for live performances and studio productions.
  • Modulation Options: Modulation capabilities allow for dynamic changes in sound parameters over time, such as filter cutoff or pitch. This variability adds movement to the sounds created, making grooves more lively and interesting, essential for capturing the listener’s attention.

What Features are Essential for Top Groovebox Synths?

The essential features for top groovebox synths include:

  • Integrated Sequencer: A robust sequencer allows users to create complex patterns and control various parameters in real-time, making it easier to compose and manipulate music on the fly.
  • Sound Engine: A high-quality sound engine is crucial for producing a wide range of sounds, from classic analog tones to modern digital textures, ensuring versatility in music styles.
  • Performance Controls: Features like knobs, pads, and sliders enable intuitive manipulation of sounds and sequences during live performances, allowing musicians to add spontaneity to their sets.
  • Connectivity Options: Comprehensive connectivity, including MIDI, USB, and audio outputs, facilitates integration with other gear and DAWs, enhancing workflow and creative possibilities.
  • Sampling Capabilities: The ability to sample sounds directly into the groovebox gives users the freedom to incorporate unique audio sources, enhancing creativity and personalization of their music.
  • User-Friendly Interface: An intuitive interface with clear navigation and accessible controls enables musicians to focus on their creativity without getting bogged down by complicated menus.
  • Sound Library: A diverse sound library provides a wealth of presets and samples that can inspire creativity and serve as starting points for new compositions.

Which Groovebox Synths are Considered the Best on the Market?

The best groovebox synths on the market combine innovative features, high-quality sound, and user-friendly interfaces.

  • Elektron Model:Cycles: This groovebox synth offers six different FM synthesis engines that can create a wide variety of sounds, from punchy drums to melodic sequences. Its intuitive layout allows for real-time parameter tweaking and performance features, making it suitable for live settings.
  • Korg electribe 2: The electribe 2 stands out with its blend of sampling and synthesis capabilities, allowing users to create intricate patterns and compositions. It is equipped with a touchpad interface and a powerful sequencer that encourages creativity and experimentation.
  • Novation Circuit Tracks: This groovebox combines a polyphonic synth with a powerful four-track sequencer, making it ideal for both live performances and studio productions. Its built-in effects and sample playback capabilities enhance sound design possibilities, while the compact form factor ensures portability.
  • Akai MPC One: Known for its legendary sampling capabilities, the MPC One integrates traditional sampling with modern synth features and a robust sequencer. Its touchscreen interface and standalone operation allow users to produce complete tracks without needing a computer.
  • Arturia MicroLab: This compact groovebox combines a variety of sounds and synthesis methods, including analog modeling and sample playback. It also features a powerful sequencer and performance tools that enable musicians to create complex arrangements with ease.

How Does the Novation Circuit Tracks Compare to Others?

Aspect Novation Circuit Tracks Other Groovebox Synths
Price $399 – Competitive pricing for its features Varies – Ranges from $200 to $800 depending on brand and features
Features Includes sequencer, synth engines, and effects Varies – May include sampling, sequencing, and different synthesis types
Sound Quality High-quality sound with versatile synthesis options Varies – Quality can range widely based on the model
Portability Compact and lightweight, ideal for travel Varies – Some models are portable, while others are more studio-oriented
MIDI Compatibility Fully supports MIDI over USB and traditional MIDI I/O Varies – Some may have limited MIDI capabilities
Build Quality and Durability Sturdy construction, designed for live performance Varies – Quality can differ significantly between brands and models
User Interface and Ease of Use Intuitive interface with a clear layout Varies – Some have complex interfaces, while others are user-friendly
Community and Support Strong community and support from Novation Varies – Some brands have more active communities than others
Battery Life Up to 4 hours on battery power Varies – Battery life can range from none to several hours

What Unique Benefits Does the Elektron Syntakt Offer?

The Elektron Syntakt offers several unique benefits that make it stand out in the realm of groovebox synths.

  • Integrated Synths and Drum Machines: The Syntakt combines both analog and digital synthesis engines, allowing users to create a wide range of sounds and rhythms seamlessly. This integration enables musicians to design complex tracks without needing external devices, enhancing workflow and efficiency.
  • Advanced Sequencing Capabilities: With its powerful sequencer, the Syntakt allows for detailed control over patterns, including parameter locking and conditional triggers. This flexibility lets users build intricate arrangements and live performances that can evolve dynamically, adding a layer of depth to their music.
  • User-Friendly Interface: The Syntakt is designed with an intuitive interface that includes a clear layout and responsive controls. This user-friendly design makes it accessible for both beginners and experienced producers, allowing them to focus more on creativity rather than navigating complex menus.
  • Extensive Connectivity Options: It features a variety of inputs and outputs, including MIDI, CV, and audio connections, making it versatile for integration with other gear. This connectivity allows users to expand their setup and experiment with different sound sources and effects, enhancing the overall sonic palette.
  • Sound Design Flexibility: The Syntakt provides various sound-shaping tools, such as effects, filters, and modulation options, giving users the ability to sculpt their sounds in detail. This level of customization ensures that artists can achieve their desired sonic identity, making it suitable for various genres and styles.
  • Performance Features: The Syntakt includes performance-oriented features like live recording, sound locking, and the ability to manipulate sounds on-the-fly. These features empower performers to engage audiences with spontaneous and creative live sets, making it an ideal tool for live electronic music acts.

Why Should You Consider Using a Groovebox Synth for Your Music Production?

You should consider using a groovebox synth for your music production because it combines multiple functionalities into a single unit, allowing for greater creativity and efficiency in the music-making process.

According to a study published in the Journal of Music Technology and Education, grooveboxes facilitate a hands-on approach to music production, encouraging experimentation and improvisation, which can lead to more innovative outcomes (Katz & Kearney, 2020). This versatility in combining sequencing, sampling, and synthesis capabilities makes grooveboxes particularly appealing for both novice and experienced musicians.

The underlying mechanism behind the popularity of groovebox synths lies in their integrated workflow. By combining MIDI sequencing and audio sampling, these devices enable musicians to quickly create complex arrangements without the need for extensive software setups or multiple hardware units. This streamlining reduces the barriers to entry for producing music, allowing users to focus on their creative expression rather than technical challenges. Additionally, the tactile controls and immediate feedback provided by grooveboxes foster an intuitive interaction with music, further enhancing the creative process.

Moreover, the groovebox’s portability and compact design make it an attractive option for musicians who require mobility and flexibility in their production environment. Research indicates that musicians who can easily transport their gear tend to engage more frequently in collaborative projects and live performances (Bennett, 2021). This accessibility encourages a community of artists to explore new genres and styles, ultimately enriching the musical landscape.

How Can You Select the Best Groovebox Synth to Fit Your Style?

Selecting the best groovebox synth to fit your style involves considering several key factors.

  • Sound Engine: The sound engine determines the quality and versatility of sounds you can create. Look for grooveboxes with a variety of synthesis methods like subtractive, FM, or wavetable, which can greatly expand your sonic palette.
  • Sequencer Capabilities: A powerful sequencer allows you to create intricate patterns and arrangements. Ensure the groovebox has user-friendly sequencing features, such as step sequencing, real-time recording, and the ability to manipulate MIDI data easily.
  • Connectivity Options: Adequate connectivity ensures that your groovebox can integrate into your existing setup. Check for MIDI, USB, and audio outputs, as well as potential integration with other gear like drum machines, synths, and DAWs.
  • Build Quality and Portability: Consider how well the groovebox is constructed and its portability. A durable design is important for live performances, while a lightweight and compact unit may be preferable for mobile music-making.
  • Workflow and User Interface: The groovebox should have an intuitive workflow that matches your creative process. Look for a user-friendly interface with clear navigation, responsive controls, and visual feedback to facilitate quick adjustments while you’re making music.
  • Price and Value: Assess whether the price aligns with the features and quality offered. Sometimes, paying a little extra can yield a much more capable and feature-rich instrument, so consider which features are essential for your style before making a decision.

What Techniques Help You Maximize Your Groovebox Synth Experience?

To enhance your groovebox synth experience, consider the following techniques:

  • Sound Layering: Combining multiple sounds can create richer textures and more complex musical arrangements. By layering different synth patches, you can achieve a unique sound that stands out, allowing each layer to complement the others.
  • Parameter Automation: Automating parameters such as filter cutoff, reverb, and modulation can bring your tracks to life. This technique allows you to create dynamic changes over time, adding movement and excitement to your sequences.
  • Using Effects: Incorporating effects like delay, distortion, and reverb can significantly enhance your sound. Effects can transform simple sounds into atmospheric or aggressive textures, helping to create a more polished and professional sound.
  • Live Performance Techniques: Engaging with your groovebox in a live setting can lead to spontaneous creativity. Techniques like finger drumming, live looping, and real-time parameter tweaking can make performances more engaging and interactive.
  • Sampling and Resampling: Using samples from external sources or your own recordings allows for greater creativity. Resampling these sounds after processing them can lead to unique results, creating an endless cycle of sound exploration.
  • Exploring MIDI Capabilities: Utilizing MIDI to connect your groovebox with other hardware or software can expand your creative possibilities. This allows for synchronized performances, control of external instruments, and enhanced sequencing capabilities.
  • Experimenting with Rhythmic Patterns: Creating unique and complex rhythmic patterns can set your music apart. Push the boundaries of traditional rhythms by exploring polyrhythms, syncopation, and groove variations to keep your tracks interesting.
  • Utilizing Presets Wisely: While presets can be a great starting point, tweaking them to fit your personal sound is essential. Modifying presets allows you to make them your own, ensuring that your music has a distinct character.
Related Post:

Leave a Comment